P&I guide · 8 min read
Letter of undertaking: P&I club security for cargo claims
Updated 16 November 2026

A cargo claimant who fears that the shipowner will not pay can ask for security. The usual answer from a P&I club is a letter of undertaking. This guide is for recovery agents and cargo insurers who ask for it and for claims handlers who receive it. It sets out what the letter does, what to check in the wording and which documents belong in the file.
Why security is asked for
A cargo claim against a shipowner is only worth what can be collected. The owner may be a single-ship company, the ship may sail on after discharge, and the claim may be heard in a forum chosen by contract. Claimants therefore ask for security early, often with the threat of arresting the ship. An arrest holds the ship in port until security is provided. Both sides usually prefer to avoid that, so a letter of undertaking from the owner's P&I club is a common middle way. Gard describes it as a way for the ship to avoid arrest or to be released from it.
Where the Arrest Convention of 1952 applies, claims for loss of or damage to goods carried in a ship, and claims under an agreement for the carriage of goods, are among the claims for which a ship may be arrested (article 1(1)(e) and (f)). The court must allow the ship to be released on sufficient bail or other security (article 5). Whether the Convention or a national rule applies depends on the place where the ship is, so confirm it there. For the claim itself, see the guides on the notice of claim to the carrier and on carrier liability limits.
Invented example. A cargo insurer has paid for wet damage to a parcel of machinery. Its recovery agent writes to the owner and the owner's P&I club, attaches the survey report and the bill of lading, and asks for security for an amount that includes interest and costs. The club asks for the policy details of the member and for the claim documents. After a few days it sends a draft letter of undertaking. The agent reads the draft, asks for two changes and receives the final signed letter. The insurer files the letter and sets a diary date for the end of the agreed extension.
What a club letter of undertaking is
A club letter of undertaking (LOU) is a promise by the club to the named beneficiary. The Swedish Club describes it as a promise that the club will pay, up to a specified amount, what the member is found legally liable for. Gard adds that the promise is conditional: the claimant must lift the arrest or agree not to arrest the ship. The letter is therefore an exchange. The claimant gives up the arrest, and the club gives a payment promise that does not depend on the owner's own funds.
Once the club has posted security, the Swedish Club notes that it cannot rely on its rules, limits or exclusions against the beneficiary. The beneficiary is paid by the club directly. The club may take counter-security from its member, such as a bank guarantee or a cash deposit. That is a matter between the club and the member and does not concern the claimant.
Clubs are not obliged to give security. The Swedish Club states that all Group clubs say in their rules that it is at the club's discretion, and that the club must first be reasonably satisfied that the claim is covered. Gard says clubs usually give security for covered claims once acceptable terms are agreed. A claim outside cover is a different case, and the club may refuse. Ask early, send the documents the club needs, and do not read a slow reply as a refusal.
A security request step by step
- Identify the ship, the owner and the club. The bill of lading, the ship's registry entry and the owner's correspondence usually show who is who.
- Send the claim, the documents behind it and the request for security to the owner and the club, with the amount you ask for.
- Agree the form. Ask for a draft letter and read it against the checklist below before you accept it.
- Agree the forum and the law that will apply to the claim, and say so in the letter.
- Ask for a written time extension, in the letter or in a separate exchange, and check which contract it covers.
- Receive the signed letter, check who signed and for whom, and file it with the request and the correspondence.
- Diary the end date of any extension and the other conditions of the letter.
What to check in the wording
No single wording suits every club and claim, and clubs have their own standard drafts. These are points to check, not a form. In Lavender Shipmanagement v Ibrahima Sory (2020), an English cargo case, the letter named the receivers and their subrogated underwriters as beneficiaries, listed the bills of lading and the nature of the claim, set a maximum amount in US dollars, and stated that the claims were subject to English law and London arbitration. Compare your own draft with it.
- Beneficiary. Your client, and its subrogated insurer if you recover in subrogation.
- Ship, voyage and cargo. The ship, the voyage and every bill of lading the letter is meant to cover.
- Amount. The maximum, and whether it includes interest and costs.
- Trigger for payment. What must happen before the club pays: an agreed sum, a judgment or an award.
- Forum and law. Court or arbitration, the place and the governing law.
- Reservations. Wording such as "without prejudice" or "without admission of liability", and what it leaves open.
- Time extension. Whether the letter or a separate exchange extends the time, and to which date.
- Suspension or release clauses. A clause that suspends or ends the undertaking in certain events, for example sanctions wording. In the same case the security was held reasonable but the recipient was not obliged to accept it, and the liability to pay was only suspended, not ended, by the clause.
- Signatory. Who signed, for whom, and with what authority.
Alternatives to a club letter
A bank guarantee or bond is the usual alternative. Gard notes that it can take several business days to arrange, may carry an expiry date and costs the owner bank fees. A cash deposit is another. The Swedish Club says it follows a firm practice of not providing cash security, with limited exceptions, and does not give guarantees payable on demand. Where liability is shared between two insurers, the other insurer may provide security for its share. A claimant who is offered something other than a club letter should check the same points as above, with extra attention to expiry dates.
The documents in the file
| Document | Who provides it | What it shows | Stage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claim and supporting documents | Claimant, insurer, recovery agent | The loss, the amount and the evidence behind them | Request |
| Request for security | Claimant or its agent | The amount asked, the date and the reply required | Request |
| Ship, owner and club details | Registry, bill of lading, owner | Who the undertaking is for and who gives it | Request |
| Draft letter of undertaking and comments | Club, claimant | The wording offered, the changes asked for and the dates | Negotiation |
| Signed letter of undertaking | Club, or its correspondent on its behalf | Beneficiary, amount, forum, law and conditions | Security given |
| Jurisdiction or arbitration agreement | Parties, or contained in the letter | Where and under which law the claim will be decided | Security given |
| Time extension in writing | Owner or club, claimant | The new date and the contract it covers | Security given |
| Arrest papers or confirmation that no arrest will follow | Claimant, lawyers | Whether an arrest was made and when it ended | Security given |
| Correspondence with owner and club | All parties | Positions, offers and dates | Throughout |
| Payment advice after settlement or award | Club, claimant | What was paid under the letter and when | Settlement |
Common gaps
- A letter filed without the draft and without the correspondence that led to it.
- The amount not checked against the claim, interest and costs.
- A bill of lading or a voyage missing from the heading of the letter.
- An extension that refers to one contract, while the claim arises under another.
- No diary date for the end of an extension or for an expiry in the letter.
- A signatory whose authority was never confirmed.
- The letter in one folder, the claim in another, and nobody who sees both.
Not legal advice. This guide describes common practice. Whether you may arrest a ship, what security you may ask for and what a letter of undertaking binds the club to depend on the law of the place, the contract and the wording. Time limits depend on the contract and the law, so confirm them for your claim (see time bars in cargo claims) and take advice from your lawyer.
FAQ
Can I insist on a letter of undertaking from the club?
No. The club decides, at its discretion under its rules, and usually first checks the cover. You can ask early and supply what it needs. If the club declines, consider whether another form, such as a bank guarantee, will do.
Does the letter replace the time bar?
No. A letter of undertaking is security for a claim. It does not by itself extend the time for bringing it. Ask for a written extension and confirm the period for your claim. The guide on recovery and subrogation and the P&I claims guide show where this fits.
Who is the beneficiary when an insurer has paid?
Usually both the receiver or assured and its subrogated insurer, as in the Lavender case above. Name the party that will bring the claim, and check this point before you sign anything that releases the ship.
Can I accept a letter with a suspension clause?
That is your decision. In the Lavender case the court held that the security was reasonable but that the recipient did not have to accept it. Read the clause, ask what it means for payment and take advice before you accept.
Dossima files these documents into one claim file per claim, keeps every version and shows what is still missing, including an extension or a letter detail you have not yet confirmed. The decision stays with you.
Sources
- Gard: the shipowner's hero, the club letter of undertaking
- The Swedish Club: comments on Rule 12, security for claims and certificates
- Winter Fisher Willis: Reasonably secure or allowed to arrest?
- Lavender Shipmanagement v Ibrahima Sory Affretement Trading, 2020 EWHC 3462 (Comm)
- International Convention relating to the Arrest of Sea-Going Ships, 1952 (text)