Cargo guide · 8 min read
Bulk cargo shortage claims: draft survey vs bill of lading
Updated 16 November 2026

A shortage claim on grain, soybeans, ore or fertiliser starts with two numbers that disagree: the figure on the bill of lading and the figure at discharge. This guide shows where each number comes from, how far a draft survey can be trusted, and which documents let you tell a real loss from a difference on paper.
Two numbers, two methods
On dry bulk the quantity is not counted. It is measured, and the two ends of the voyage use different methods. At loading, the shipper's figure normally comes from shore measurement, such as a weighbridge, a belt scale or a silo scale. That figure goes into the bill of lading. At discharge, the receiver may use a shore scale, a draft survey or both. A shortage claim is the difference between these two figures. The first question is always which method produced each.
This guide covers dry bulk. Liquid bulk is measured by other methods, such as shore tanks and ullage, and is not covered here. For the general set of documents in a cargo claim, see the guide to marine cargo claim documents.
Invented example. A cargo of 30,000 tonnes of soybeans is loaded at a river terminal. The shipper's scale figure, 30,000 tonnes, goes into the bill of lading. The master orders a draft survey after loading and gets a lower figure, which is entered in the mate's receipt. At discharge, the receiver's shore scale shows less than the bill of lading. The receiver claims for the difference. The claim handler asks four questions. Which method produced each figure? What do the mate's receipt and the bill of lading say? Was a draft survey done before discharge? Is the difference larger or smaller than the accuracy of the method?
Where the bill of lading figure comes from
Gard explains that the shipper's quantity, usually based on shore measurements, is inserted in the bill of lading and that the master has no means of checking those measurements. The draft survey at loading is the vessel's only independent check. Under Article III rule 3 of the Hague-Visby Rules, the carrier does not have to state a quantity that it has reasonable ground to suspect is inaccurate, or that it had no reasonable means of checking. Under rule 4, the bill of lading is prima facie evidence of the goods received, and proof to the contrary is not admitted once it has passed to a third party acting in good faith. Under rule 5, the shipper is deemed to have guaranteed the accuracy of the particulars at the time of shipment.
In practice the bill of lading figure can bind the carrier even if it was wrong, in particular towards a good-faith holder. How the figure was written also matters. The mate's receipt and the bill of lading wording show what the master knew and recorded at loading. Whether any clause protects the carrier depends on the law that applies and on the facts, so treat it as a question to confirm for your claim.
How a draft survey works, and where it goes wrong
A draft survey calculates the weight of the cargo from the ship's displacement. The surveyor reads the draught marks, takes the density of the water, and calculates displacement from the ship's tables. The surveyor then deducts everything that is not cargo: ballast, bunkers, fresh water, stores and the ship's constant. The cargo is the difference between the final survey and the initial one.
Gard calls it “not an exact science” and describes a properly performed survey as accurate to about 0.5% for dry bulk. West of England says the calculated figure typically varies by between 0.5 and 1.0%. It lists these sources of error:
- Draught readings. Fouled or rusty marks, waves, poor light and an oblique view from a high wharf. West of England gives a two centimetre error in the mean draught as roughly 68 tonnes on a Handysize and 300 tonnes on a Capesize.
- Density. The wrong hydrometer, poor sampling or a reading error. A density that is too low shows an apparent shortage, and one that is too high an apparent surplus.
- Ballast and other tanks. Sounding errors, mud or sediment counted as cargo, leaking valves, and tanks that are not fully pumped out.
- Weights not accounted for. Bilge water, silt in the double bottoms, bunkers, fresh water and sludge.
- Trim, squat, hog and sag. The ship can change trim or sink alongside a berth, and the hull can deflect, in particular on smaller or older ships.
- The ship's constant. West of England says a notable difference between the constant at loading and at discharge points to an error.
None of this means a draft survey is unreliable. It means that a draft survey report is only as good as the readings, calculations and records behind it. A handler who has only the final figure cannot test it. The full report, with the readings and the tank soundings, can be tested.
Shore scale or draft survey at discharge
There is no single answer on which figure counts. The contract of sale, the charter party, the local law and the port authorities can each prescribe a method. Gard notes, for example, that in Argentina the rule on who chooses the method has changed over the years, and that customs can still check the declared weight. It also says that it is a misconception that the shore scale figures are the only figures accepted, and that a draft survey is a point of reference even where the bill of lading shows shore figures. Check which method the contracts and the local rules prescribe for your claim.
Gard suggests a draft survey before discharge begins, with the consignee invited to attend. It also points to hatch seals that are intact before discharge, ideally witnessed by the consignee, as a sign that cargo was not lost on the voyage. Months later, a shortage claim often turns on records like these.
A bulk shortage claim step by step
- Write down both figures and the method that produced each: shore scale, belt scale, draft survey or other.
- Read the mate's receipts and the bills of lading side by side. Note the quantity, any remark such as “said to weigh” or “weight unknown” and whether the draft survey figure is stated.
- Collect the draft survey reports at loading and before discharge, with the readings, densities and tank soundings, not only the final result.
- Collect the shore weighing records at both ends: weighbridge or scale tickets, tallies and the receiver's outturn report.
- Calculate the difference in tonnes and as a percentage of the bill of lading figure. Compare it with the accuracy of the methods used.
- Check the hold records: hold inspection and cleanliness at loading, hatch seals at discharge, the statement of facts and the deck log. See statement of facts vs deck log.
- Send a notice of claim and confirm the time limit that applies. See the guides on the notice of claim to the carrier and on cargo claim time bars.
- If you pursue the carrier in recovery, look at what the claim can reach before you spend on it. See carrier liability limits.
The documents of a bulk shortage claim
| Document | Who provides it | What it shows | Stage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sale contract and charter party | Seller, buyer, charterer, owner | Which weighing method and which survey the parties agreed, and any clause on quantity | Contract |
| Shipper's weight certificate, weighbridge or scale tickets at loading | Shipper, terminal | The shore figure behind the bill of lading, and the method that produced it | Loading |
| Mate's receipts | Master, ship's agent | What the ship recorded at loading, including any remark on quantity | Loading |
| Bills of lading | Carrier, ship's agent | The quantity stated, the wording on weight and who holds the bill | Loading |
| Draft survey report at loading, with readings and soundings | Surveyor, ship | The ship's own figure at loading and the data behind it | Loading |
| Hold inspection and hold cleanliness records | Surveyor, ship, charterers | The condition of the holds before loading | Loading |
| Statement of facts and deck log | Agent, ship | Times of loading, discharge, hatch opening and closing, and weather | Voyage and discharge |
| Hatch seal records | Ship, consignee | Whether the holds stayed sealed from loading to discharge | Discharge |
| Draft survey report before discharge, with readings and soundings | Surveyor, ship | The ship's figure before discharge, to compare with loading | Discharge |
| Weighbridge or scale tickets and tallies at discharge, outturn report | Receiver, terminal, surveyor | The figure received and the method that produced it | Discharge |
| Notice of claim and the carrier's reply | Claimant, carrier | When and how the other side was told | Claim |
Common gaps in a bulk shortage file
- Only the final draft survey figure is on file, without the readings, densities and soundings.
- No draft survey before discharge, so there is nothing to compare with loading.
- The mate's receipt and the bill of lading say different things, and no one has noted why.
- The weighing method at discharge is not recorded, so the two figures cannot be compared.
- No record of the hatch seals before discharge.
- A difference of less than the accuracy of the method is claimed without noting the accuracy.
- The ship's constant at loading and discharge is not compared.
Not legal advice. This guide describes common practice and club guidance, not the law of any country. Accuracy figures are those stated by the sources listed below and depend on the ship, the conditions and the surveyor. Which figure counts, whether a clause on weight protects the carrier, and the time limits depend on the contract and the law that applies. Confirm them for your claim and take advice from your lawyer where needed.
FAQ
Is a shortage of 0.5% a real loss?
Not necessarily. Gard describes 0.5% as the accuracy of a properly performed draft survey and says smaller differences are usually differences on paper. West of England says the calculated figure can vary by 0.5 to 1.0%. A difference of that size alone does not show that cargo went missing.
Does “weight unknown” protect the carrier?
Not always. Gard says that some jurisdictions do not uphold such clauses and that the words are not enough where the difference is not normal or customary, in particular if the master has determined the quantity. Treat it as a question of law and facts for your claim.
Which counts at discharge, the shore scale or the draft survey?
It depends on the contracts and on the local rules, which differ from port to port. Record the method used for each figure and check what the contracts and the law prescribe.
Do I need a draft survey at both ends?
It makes the comparison possible. Without a survey at loading, you cannot test the bill of lading figure. Without one before discharge, you cannot show how much the ship carried.
Dossima files these documents into one claim file per claim, keeps every version of each report and shows what is still missing, such as a draft survey you have not yet received. The decision stays with you.
Sources
- Gard: draft surveys, a critical tool to defend dry bulk cargo shortage claims
- West of England: inaccuracies in draught surveys (loss prevention bulletin)
- Gard: Argentina, determining the cargo quantity for bulk cargoes, are shore figures mandatory?
- Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1971, Schedule: the Hague-Visby Rules, Article III (legislation.gov.uk)