Cargo guide · 7 min read
Letter of protest in cargo claims: when and how to write one
Updated 16 November 2026

At the discharge port, a shortage, a damaged package or a delay is easiest to prove on the day. A letter of protest puts the facts and your reservation of rights in writing, addressed to the party that can answer for them. This guide covers who writes it, what goes in it, how it differs from a note of protest and a notice of claim, and what to file with it.
What a letter of protest is for
A letter of protest records, close to the event, that something went wrong and that the writer does not accept responsibility for it. It goes to a party with some control over the matter: a ship's master, a terminal, a stevedore, a shipper or a carrier. It says what happened, when and with what effect, and it reserves the writer's rights. Its value as evidence varies from one jurisdiction to another, so treat it as a record of timing and position, not as proof in itself.
The typical triggers at the discharge port are a quantity short of the bill of lading, damage found at discharge, damage done by stevedores or terminal equipment, a delay, or goods that arrive in a different condition from the one described in the documents. At the load port the same letter is used the other way round, for example by a master who records that cargo was loaded in poor condition. Our guide to marine cargo claim documents covers the papers around it.
Invented example. A consignment of 120 pallets of packaged food is discharged from a container ship. On the last day the receiver's agent finds 12 pallets with crushed corners and 4 pallets missing against the delivery order. The agent writes to the terminal and to the carrier's agent the same afternoon. The letter lists the pallets, the times of the tally, the container numbers, the photographs taken and a request to sign for receipt. It also states that the receiver reserves its rights. The terminal signs for receipt only. The agent files the letter, the tally and the photographs with the survey instruction.
Who writes to whom
- Receiver or its agent to the master, owner or carrier's agent: shortage, damage found at discharge, condition of the cargo on arrival, delay in delivery.
- Receiver or its agent to the terminal or stevedores: damage during handling ashore, goods released or delivered in a different state from the one on arrival.
- Master to shippers, charterers, the terminal or stevedores: cargo loaded in bad condition, differences between ship and shore figures, damage done by shore labour or equipment, delay not caused by the ship.
- Insurer or surveyor: usually does not write the first letter but needs to see it. It tells them what was said and when.
Address the letter to a named person or company, not to "whom it may concern". If the other side will not sign for receipt, record that in writing and send a second short letter saying the first was handed over and not signed. When a master receives a letter that asks for acknowledgement, club guidance suggests wording such as "received without prejudice and without admission of liability" or "received without prejudice and for receipt only". Clubs also advise masters to contact the local P&I correspondent before signing or answering anything that touches liability.
What the letter should contain
- Date, place, the writer and the person or company addressed.
- The vessel, voyage, port and berth, and the cargo with its bill of lading number, marks and quantity.
- The facts, in short sentences: what was found, where, at what time and by whom. Use the tally, the draft survey figures or the survey findings where they exist and do not add opinions about cause.
- The quantities involved: units short, units damaged, weight or volume as relevant, and the basis of the figure.
- References: container and seal numbers, delivery order, tally sheet numbers, photograph numbers, survey instruction.
- A reservation of rights: that the writer holds the addressee responsible for the consequences and reserves all rights, without describing the legal basis in detail.
- A request to acknowledge receipt by signature, with the date and time, and the name of the person who signs.
- A list of what is attached.
Letter of protest, note of protest and notice of claim
| Document | Who makes it | To whom | What it does |
|---|---|---|---|
| Letter of protest | Receiver, agent, master, shipper or terminal | A named party that can control or answer for the matter | Records facts and reserves rights close to the event. Not sworn. |
| Note of protest | Master | Made as a declaration before a notary, consul or similar, in some jurisdictions | A sworn or attested record of an event, such as heavy weather. The club correspondent can say what the local rules require. |
| Notice of claim | Cargo interests or their insurer | The carrier or its agent, and others who may be liable | Starts the claim in writing and, under the Hague-Visby Rules, serves as the written notice of loss or damage. |
The three overlap, and none replaces another. A letter of protest to the terminal does not tell the carrier that a claim is coming. The Hague-Visby Rules, Article III rule 6, ask for written notice of loss or damage and its general nature to be given to the carrier or its agent at the port of discharge before or at the time of removal, or within three days if the loss or damage is not apparent. If notice is not given, removal is prima facie evidence that the goods were delivered as described in the bill of lading. Notice is not needed where the condition was jointly surveyed or inspected at receipt. The rules also set a one-year period for suit, which the parties can extend by agreement after the cause of action has arisen. Other conventions and national laws use other periods, so confirm them for your claim. Our guides on the notice of claim to the carrier and on time bars in cargo claims cover this in more detail.
What to file with it
| Document | Who provides it | What it shows | Stage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Letter of protest with the signed or unsigned copy | Writer | What was said, to whom and whether it was acknowledged | Event |
| Tally sheets and delivery receipts, with notes made at delivery | Terminal, stevedore, receiver | Quantity and condition at the moment of discharge and handover | Event |
| Photographs and video with date, time and place | Receiver, agent, surveyor | Visible condition of the cargo, packing, containers and seals | Event |
| Statement of facts and deck log extracts | Agent, master | Times of arrival, discharge, weather and interruptions. See statement of facts vs deck log | Event |
| Draft survey, outturn report or survey report | Surveyor | Quantity figures and findings on cause and extent | Evidence |
| Bill of lading, packing list, commercial invoice | Shipper, carrier, seller | What was shipped and in what apparent condition | Evidence |
| Notice of claim to the carrier and its reply | Cargo interests or insurer | That the carrier was told in writing and what it answered | Notice |
| Replies to the letter, including refusals to sign | Addressee | The other side's position and the date of its answer | Notice |
Common gaps
- A letter sent to the ship but not to the terminal or stevedores that handled the cargo, or the other way round.
- No time on the letter, or times that differ from the tally or the statement of facts.
- Quantities without the basis: no tally, no survey, no weighbridge ticket.
- A letter signed on receipt without a note of what it was signed for, or signed without any reservation where one was possible.
- Photographs without date, place or container number.
- A letter of protest in the file but no notice of claim to the carrier.
- A later version of the letter or the survey that replaces an earlier one without the earlier one being kept.
Not legal advice. This guide describes common practice. The effect of a letter of protest, the formalities for a note of protest and the periods for notice and suit depend on the contract, the convention or national law that applies and the port. Confirm them for your claim with your lawyer, the P&I correspondent or a specialist adviser.
FAQ
Does a letter of protest preserve my claim?
It records the facts and your reservation, which helps, but it does not replace the notice of claim or the time for suit. Confirm what the contract and the law require for your claim.
Can I sign for receipt only?
Often that is the safest form of acknowledgement, because it confirms that the paper arrived and nothing more. Some ports ask for documents to be signed without reservation. Guidance from a P&I club on one such port warns that unreserved signing leaves the owner's position uncertain and that local courts may treat the documents as an admission. Ask the local correspondent before you sign.
Who can issue a letter of protest?
Any party that has a complaint against a party that can control or answer for the matter. In cargo claims these are mainly receivers and their agents, masters, shippers and terminals.
How is it different from a note of protest?
A note of protest is a master's declaration of an event, made before a notary or consul in some jurisdictions, and is attested. A letter of protest is a letter to a named party and is not sworn.
Dossima files these documents into one claim file per claim, keeps every version of the letter and the survey and shows what is still missing, including a notice of claim you have not yet sent or confirmed. The decision stays with you.
Sources
- Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1971, Schedule: Hague-Visby Rules, Article III rule 6 (legislation.gov.uk)
- West of England: Iraq grain shortage and damage claims at Umm Qasr
- West of England: P&I Guidelines UK (notes and letters of protest, acknowledgement wording)
- The Swedish Club: comments on Rule 10, sea protests (10.4.3.2)