Hull & machinery guide · 8 min read
Machinery damage claims: the evidence an H&M claim needs
Updated 16 November 2026

Machinery claims turn on cause. Whether a main engine bearing, a turbocharger or a steering gear failure is covered depends on why it failed, and the file has to show that. This guide covers the common types of claim, how the cover is usually structured and the evidence the claim needs.
What a machinery damage claim is
A machinery damage claim is a hull and machinery (H&M) claim for damage to the ship's engines and other machinery: the main engine, auxiliary engines and generators, crankshaft and bearings, turbochargers, shafting and propellers, and steering gear. Unlike a grounding or a collision, a machinery failure often has no outside event. The first question is therefore why it happened, and the file has to answer it.
Invented example. A bulk carrier's main engine stops after an oil mist alarm. The crew finds a damaged crankpin bearing, and the engine maker's service engineer attends. The failed bearing shells and the lubricating oil sample are kept. A laboratory report finds metal debris in the oil. The owner's superintendent says the bearing was last inspected at the previous overhaul. Underwriters' surveyor asks for the alarm log, the running hours, the oil analyses of the last year and the maintenance records. The claim now depends on what these documents say about the cause.
What is commonly covered and excluded
The structure differs between the two main sets of conditions. The Institute Time Clauses Hulls (ITCH) cover named perils. Clause 6.2 of the ITCH 1/10/83 insures loss of or damage to the ship caused by, among other things, bursting of boilers, breakage of shafts or any latent defect in the machinery or hull, negligence of master, officers, crew or pilots, and negligence of repairers or charterers who are not an assured. This is often called the Inchmaree clause. It is subject to the proviso that the loss did not result from want of due diligence by the assured, owners or managers. Under the ITCH the assured must prove that the loss was caused by an insured peril.
The Nordic Marine Insurance Plan works the other way round. It covers all risks except the exclusions, which include war perils and wear and tear, and the insurer has to prove that an exclusion applies. Gard's comparison notes that damage to defective parts approved by class is covered under the Nordic Plan, and that damage from contaminated lubricating oil, cooling water or feed water is excluded, which creates a duty to act once contamination is known.
- Wear and tear and inadequate maintenance are excluded under both sets of conditions. A worn part that fails and damages other parts is the usual dispute.
- Latent defect is the key question for a failed part. How each wording treats the cost of repairing the defective part itself differs, so read the clause.
- Crew negligence is covered under the ITCH named perils, subject to due diligence. Such cases often turn on whether the failure was an operating error or a gap in the owner's systems.
- Repairer negligence can be covered as well, and it also points to a possible recovery against the repairer.
Policies also carry a deductible, and the ITCH 1/10/83 apply it to each accident or occurrence. Some schedules have separate terms for machinery claims. Check the deductible clause and the schedule of the actual policy.
A machinery damage claim step by step
- The engine stops or an alarm sounds. The crew secures the engine, logs the events and keeps the alarm and data logger records.
- The owner gives notice to the hull insurers through the broker, before survey. The ITCH 1/10/83 also require notice to the nearest Lloyd's agent if the ship is abroad.
- Surveyors for the owner and the underwriters attend. The engine maker's service engineer or the repairer opens the engine up. Damaged parts are tagged and kept.
- Samples of oil and fuel are taken. Where cause is open, parts and samples go to a laboratory for a failure analysis.
- Tenders are taken for the repair. Under the ITCH 1/10/83, underwriters may decide the repair port and have a say in the repairer and the tenders.
- The repair is carried out and invoiced. Class may attend and issue a condition of class.
- The documents go to the adjuster. Questions of cover are decided by the underwriters under the policy.
- Where a manufacturer or repairer may be liable, the insurer may pursue a recovery. See subrogation and recovery.
The evidence a machinery claim needs
| Document | Who provides it | What it shows | Stage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engine room logbook and alarm log | Owner, from the ship | The sequence before and after the failure: alarms, pressures, temperatures, actions taken | Casualty |
| Data logger and monitoring printouts | Owner, from the ship | Trends over the days before the failure, with times | Casualty |
| Running hours and overhaul history | Owner or manager | Hours since the last overhaul of the damaged component | Cause |
| Planned maintenance system (PMS) records | Owner or manager | Which maintenance was due and done, and by whom | Cause |
| Lubricating oil analyses | Owner, laboratory | Condition of the oil in the weeks and months before the failure | Cause |
| Fuel records, bunker delivery note and fuel analysis | Owner, supplier, laboratory | Which fuel was used and its quality | Cause |
| Retained bunker samples | Owner, ship | A sample of the fuel delivered, kept on board | Cause |
| Class survey reports and condition of class | Classification society | Class status of the machinery and any earlier findings | Survey |
| Maker's service report | Engine maker or service engineer | Findings on opening up, measurements and the maker's view on cause | Survey |
| Failure analysis or laboratory report | Independent laboratory or expert | Metallurgical findings on fracture, material and fatigue | Cause |
| Damaged parts, tagged and with a record of who holds them | Owner, repairer, surveyor | The physical evidence for any later test or dispute | Cause |
| Surveyor's report for the insurers | Underwriters' surveyor | Cause, extent, repair scope and reasonableness of costs | Survey |
| Superintendent's reports and photographs | Owner's superintendent | Condition found, work done and decisions taken | Survey and repair |
| Repair specification, quotations and tender comparison | Owner, repairers | Scope, price, time and why the repairer was chosen | Repair |
| Invoices from the repairer, makers and suppliers | Repairers, makers, suppliers | Costs charged, split by item | Repair |
| Policy, clauses, schedule and deductible | Owner or broker | Perils, conditions, notice requirements and deductible | All stages |
Why to keep damaged parts and to inspect jointly
The cause often cannot be established by looking at the engine alone. The failed part is the best evidence, and once it is scrapped nobody can test it again. Forensic engineers describe removing the failed parts from the engine, preserving them for possible materials analysis and recording a chain of custody from the ship to the laboratory. Laboratory work can include fractography, metallographic sections, hardness testing and chemical analysis.
Keep every damaged component until the underwriters' surveyor has seen it and agreed what happens to it. Tag each part, photograph it where it was found and record who holds it. Where several interests are involved, such as the owner, the maker and the repairer, inspections are often arranged so that each side sees the same parts. The terms of such an inspection, including whether it is without prejudice, are for the parties to agree.
Samples. The fuel sample retained under MARPOL is kept for at least 12 months from delivery, but IMO's sampling guidelines say it is to be used solely to determine MARPOL compliance. For an engine investigation, ask which other samples exist: drip samples taken at bunkering, lubricating oil samples and the supplier's samples. The Swedish Club recommends drip sampling at bunkering and laboratory analysis of lubricating oil at regular intervals.
Maintenance and oil records: what they show
The Swedish Club's study of main engine damage reports lubrication failure as the most common cause of damage, followed by incorrect maintenance or repairs, and the most expensive damage on the crankshaft and bearings. So surveyors ask first for oil analyses, the maintenance history of the component, whether alarms were handled as the manufacturer requires, and whether overhauls were done to the maker's intervals.
A complete PMS record helps both sides. It supports the assured where maintenance was done, and it shows the underwriters where it was not. An overhaul that was due and not recorded needs an explanation, and an unexplained gap is hard to defend under a due diligence condition. For the hull side of the file see our hull and machinery documents guide. If the casualty also took the ship out of service, see loss of hire claims.
Common gaps in a machinery damage file
- Engine logs and alarm records that start only at the failure, not days before it.
- No dated notice, or notice after the survey had started.
- Missing PMS entries or oil analyses for the damaged component.
- Damaged parts scrapped or lost before the underwriters' surveyor saw them.
- No record of who held the parts between the ship, the repairer and the laboratory.
- A laboratory report with no link to the part or sample it describes.
- Quotations that changed during the repair, with only the final one on file.
Not legal or coverage advice. This guide describes common practice and two well-known sets of conditions. Cover, exclusions, deductibles and notice duties depend on the policy, its version of the clauses and the governing law. Check them for each claim, and ask your broker, adjuster or lawyer where needed.
FAQ
Is a machinery breakdown covered by hull insurance?
It can be, depending on the cause and the conditions. Wear and tear is generally excluded, while latent defect and negligence of the crew or of repairers may be covered. Check the clause of the actual policy.
What is the Inchmaree clause?
The common name for the additional perils clause in the Institute Time Clauses Hulls, clause 6.2 in the 1/10/83 version. It covers latent defect, breakage of shafts, bursting of boilers and negligence of certain people, subject to a due diligence proviso.
Why do insurers ask to see the damaged parts?
Because the cause often depends on the part itself. A failed bearing or a fractured shaft can show whether the cause was material, fatigue, lubrication or wear. Keep the parts until the surveyor has seen them.
Can the owner recover from the maker or the repairer?
Possibly. Insurers who pay may pursue a recovery against a liable manufacturer or repairer. The same evidence supports it, so keep it intact.
Dossima files these documents into one claim file per casualty, keeps every version, and shows what is still missing, with the source behind each entry. The decision stays with you.
Sources
- Gard: Brief overview of the Nordic Plan and Institute Time Clauses (Hulls)
- Institute Time Clauses Hulls 1/10/83 (text)
- The Swedish Club: Main Engine Damage
- J.S. Held: Marine casualty investigation, engineering and forensic accounting
- IMO: Guidelines for the sampling of fuel oil (MSC-MEPC.2/Circ.18).pdf)